Is the Book Always Better than the Movie?

With a slew of movies coming out that have beenand actors really know the story, this is when the best
modeled after popular books, it seems to be aresults occur.The trouble is when a movie is just
prevalent theme that the book is almost always betterthrown together, without the time being taken to
than the movie. Perfect case in point is the latestmaintain the integrity of the written story, and the
release "The DaVinci Code", an adaptation of themoney to make the sets as realistic as possible, or
wildly popular and controversial work of fiction bysometimes it's just plain old misdirection.Take for
author Dan Brown. I loved the book, couldn't put itexample the adaptation of the science fiction novel
down. But the movie was average.If I would have onlyBattlefield Earth by L. Ron Hubbard. The movie,
seen the movie and not read the book, I would havefeaturing John Travolta dressed in alien garb, ended up
walked out of the theater with the conclusion that Ibeing a gross misinterpretation of the story, as well as
would not have wanted to read such a mediocrethe brunt of several jokes around Oscar time, due to
book. Of course for every status quo, there areits poor reception from audiences and critics.Or how
always exceptions to the rule. The movies "Angela'sabout the unforgettable Ishtar starring Dustin Hoffman
Ashes" based on Irish novelist Frank McCourt's storyand Warren Beatty? This atrocity was the brunt of
of a poor Irish family ended up being an excellent film,jokes for years after its dismal release as the most
well acted with a perfect cast and authenticboring movie ever made. And what about this list of
feel.Another example of a good movie based on abombs that originated as well spun novels and novellas,
book is the autobiography about an embitteredonly to be poorly translated to the big screen?-
Vietnam veteran, Ron Kovic, played in the big screenDangerous Minds
adaptation by Tom Cruise (before he was annoying).- Dune
The film ended up being a heart breaking protrayal of- The First Wive's Club
a man who served his country in good faith, and then- Freaky Friday
lost his legs and seemed to be cast off and forgotten- Girl Interrupted (this may just be my opinion though)
by the very government he fought to protect.Let's not- The Ghost and the Darkness
also forget an excellent silver screen adaptation of the- Little WomenAnd the list goes on. Just goes to
novel Dr. Zhivago, played by Omar Sharif, and theshow, the majority of the time, one's imagination can
story of his unrequited love for Lara Antipova, playedproduce far more vivid and emotionally moving images
by the beautiful Julie Christie. This masterpiece of a filmthan that of a Hollywood director, or any amount of
was directed by David Lean with a true authenticityspecial effects.
and loyalty to the story. It seems that if the director